4th Quarter Macro And Market Outlook


Earnings could provide a rough patch as companies announce lower revised estimates due to trade concerns.

Do not expect a trade agreement with China as President Xi simply waits out President Trump.

Oil prices are moving to the high-end of what I believe will be the oil price range during the “peak oil plateau” which is set to last about a decade.

Investor Sentiment is average, but a year-end buyback indused rally could finally set the stock market up for a “euphoria” moment.

As predicted last summer and this spring, the S&P is approaching 3000 and is in a topping process that could last months or a couple more years.

This week I am reintroducing a piece that I did for years for clients of my investment advisory. I am moving it to Seeking Alpha so a wider audience can tell me that I’m wrong about things.

Each quarter, I will brush over my general outlook for the economy, corporate health and markets. It is a summary piece, so one cup of coffee should do. I will touch back on some of these topics in more detailed pieces later.  

The Economy Is Doing Well

In my recent free Friday webinar, I spend several minutes covering the underlying weakness in the economy which is a widening bifurcation between haves and have nots. That is serious problem, but not one that will be solved quickly, nor one that is ready to tilt the economy into recession. 

The 2nd Quarter GDP was unrevised and remained at 4.2%. A combination of factors are contributing to the strong GDP.

The years of stimulus by the Federal Reserve is being used by the economy finally. After years of the perception of a not business friendly administration, President Trump has clearly unleashed some animal spirits. 

The tax cuts are certainly having an impact as consumer spending is strong and corporations are doing well (more on that below). The tax cuts will only have a temporary impact however, and we will need to monitor that in the next year or two. 

Potentially the most important thing for the strong economy has been the emergence of the U.S. energy sector. I discussed this way back in 2012 when I predicted GDP prints in the 4% range in the latter part of this decade. That forecast is now coming true. 

In the big picture, the economy is strong as unemployment runs low and inflation is near the target 2% rate. Credit is slowly tightening as the Fed raises interest rates and shrinks its balance sheet, but the impact isn’t likely to be felt this quarter.

On several occasions, I have discussed the Federal Reserve’s approach under Chairman Powell. What has me concerned is that I believe the Fed is making 2 huge mistakes. 

As I have repeated in my “slow growth forever” articles, deflation, not inflation, is the real boogeyman. Chair Powell must be careful not to overestimate inflation due to past monetary stimulus as demographic headwinds will continue to blow and blow harder in the coming decade.

In a recent interview, Stanley Druckenmiller, a former manager of the Soros Quantum Fund and Chairman of Duquesne Capital, who now manages his own ten figure net worth, points out that the tightening of credit is likely to lead to a financial crisis at some point. I agree it could, but am not necessarily sure it will, and certainly not imminently. 

In the National Association for Business Economics latest survey, 51 economists was generally positive: 

“The median forecast for growth in inflation-adjusted gross domestic product (real GDP) from the fourth quarter (Q4) of 2017 to the fourth quarter of 2018 is 3.1%, a 0.3-percentage-point increase from the June 2018 NABE Outlook survey. The median forecast for real GDP growth from Q4 2018 to Q4 2019 calls for a moderation to 2.5%—unchanged from the previous survey. The panel anticipates economic growth in 2018 will be stronger than the actual 2.2% annual real GDP growth rate in 2017. On an annual basis, real GDP growth in 2018 is expected to be 2.9%, a slight rise from the 2.8% in the June survey, while the forecast for average annual real GDP growth in 2019 of 2.7% remains unchanged.” 

The economists main concerns centered around trade issues as 41% named that as their primary risk factor. The group does not see a recession this year or next as 56% felt it was unlikely.

I have suggested the possibility of a “skip-straight” recession starting in Q1 of 2019. That is, a flat to down quarter followed by an up quarter, followed by a down quarter. I might be a bit early on this, but a jagged economy, in this “on time” inventory world, makes more sense to me than a protracted downturn.

In short, the economy is doing well, but some clouds are forming. We will want to see if the Federal Reserve oversteps as historically they have and if a trade war with China has wider fallout.

Earnings Might Be Peaking On Trade Tensions

Corporate earnings growth has been over 20% for three consecutive quarters. That is a massive run. It is largely due to the short-term impact of tax breaks. 

As I have discussed, the tax breaks have added some juice to the economy in general, but also fueled corporate stock buybacks. The reduction in share count is fueling earnings advances. 

In my heavily read and criticized The Buyback Bubble Will End Badly article, I discuss that once the corporate buybacks slowdown, likely in 2019, and the economy moderates a bit due to less monetary liquidity, then the “slow growth forever” world takes over again. When that happens, it is not really a matter of “if,” we will likely see a substantial stock market correction and possibly the first cyclical bear market in a long time.

In the short-term however, the stock market looks poised for a strong fourth quarter coming out of earnings. Through last week, 98 out of 500 companies had issued earnings guidance for the 4th quarter. 74 gave negative guidance. That is 76% which is slightly higher than the usual 71% that give negative guidance.

To my mind, the negative guidance, largely pointing at trade issues, has been given to lower the bar for companies to get over. I think they will get over those bars as the impact of ongoing trade impasses with China will not likely be felt until next year. 

On top of being able to get over earnings forecasts, corporations have about $400 billion of unused authorized buybacks to use. Much of that will get used in November and December. While there are buybacks during earnings, only preplanned buybacks are allowed. Discretionary buybacks must not precede earnings announcements, but can pick up again after.

As you can see in these charts from Yardeni Research, stock buybacks are at a record high for the year – again, that contributes to earnings per share as shares a taken out of circulation: 

S&P Stock Buybacks

Below, the quarterly buybacks that have held the market up are apparent. The end of the year could be the biggest quarter yet for buybacks and I believe very likely will be: 

Quarterly S&P Stock BuybacksThe trade noise (for now it’s noise) and a slowdown in buybacks during earnings could lead to some October choppiness. I think that is volatility to be bought for a swing trade at least. Clients and subscribers will be selling a bevy of cash-secured puts expiring in December and January.

Investor Sentiment Could Hit Euphoria Soon

If the rally I see ending the year occurs, then we might finally see the “euphoric” peak of this stock bull market soon. People chase performance, that is all there is too that. It’s not a wise strategy, but a majority of people employ that approach.

In the conversation below, which took place July 6, 2017, I told Mark Yusko that I did not believe the markets were “delusional” or euphoric yet. I bet a shiny nickel that the S&P 500 would run to 3000 plus by 2019 before the next bear market. We are of course right on top of 3000 now. 

Yusko Spano Twitter Market Euphoria

I stand by that S&P forecast. Although, this April I moved my prediction up by announcing in an article that The S&P Is About To Rally To 3000:

“The S&P 500 could run to 3000 by year-end or early next year on the last Goldilocks rally.”

Of course, I was ridiculed for that as well.

Currently, investor sentiment is about average per the American Association of Individual Investors:

AAII Investor SentimentCNN Money agrees: 

CNN Fear & GreedFunny things happen when people catch a case of “FOMO” (fear of missing out) though. They will chase, chase, chase, and rationalize every click of the mouse and addition of risk. 

If this rally occurs, and you are watching it around the holidays, rather than giving into a case of FOMO, you should really pick-up a case of FOGYAK (fear of getting your assets kicked – that has been modified for family audiences). 

The rally later in December and into January will be a rally to sell into most likely – if it occurs. 

Valuations Are High And Higher Than You Think

Once again, here are some of the most stolen charts on the internet from the excellent Doug Short and Jill Mislinksi. I will only showone, but you can click the link in the last paragraph to see more. 

Here is the average of four valuation measures and the 10-year nominal return expectation from here: 

Stock Market Valuations
What that chart means is that stocks are historically expensive. The second most expensive in fact. Stocks are approaching a 3rd standard deviation event and that’s only happened one other time, during the tech wreck when NASDAQ lost nearly 90%. Valuations weren’t this high prior to the financial crisis. 

Here’s the kicker though, once the buybacks fall off, which is virtually guaranteed as there’s only so much money to be repatriated, the earnings picture will get materially worse in this “slow growth forever” world. 

Note: if you don’t understand or accept “slow growth forever” please don’t just trust me, read Minneapolis Fed President //medium.com/@neelkashkari” rel=”nofollow” style=”box-sizing: border-box; background-color: transparent; color: rgb(2, 73, 153); outline: 0px;”>Neel Kashkari (a Republican) or former Treasury Secretary Larry Summers (a Democrat). There are plenty of others as well.  

Of course, “things could be different” this time, but those are pretty dangerous words. While I am pretty bullish on the rest of this year, I am likely to become very cautious again next year. 

Oil Prices Create Additional Economic Pressure

As I have covered repeatedly, oil is a primary concern for the economy. The black goo isn’t quite as important as it was before the financial crisis, now that tech has proliferated everything, but it runs near the top of “most important” global economic factors. 

Oil Kirk SpanoWith the price of oil now over $80 globally and approaching that level in the United States, the question we must ask is when does oil put pressure on consumers. The answer is soon if it rises anymore.

I discussed the “Goldilocks” price for oil soon after I reiterated my call that oil would in fact rise to $80 per barrel. I suspect that Saudi Arabia will be able to keep oil prices from rising much more. I do find it laughable though that President Trump is blaming OPEC for the current oil price. 

Oil has risen because of two things lately. First, U.S. production is flattening out due to bottlenecks because of a lack of pipelines in Texas. Second, the U.S. sanctions on Iran have taken a million barrels of supply out of the international oil equation. That’s a pretty big deal. 

That all said, oil as it rises, puts a dent into American consumers in particular as we are so car dependent. Depending on the study, we can see that gasoline that approaches $4 per gallon starts to impede consumer spending.

Here is something anecdotal. As many of you know, I did a 3700 mile road trip around the midwest and east coast this August. I’ve never had a harder time finding hotels on short notice (which I do, because I don’t know exactly where I’ll be day to day throughout these annual jaunts). Venues and attractions were busy almost everywhere.

I chalk this up to a stronger and confident consumer, as well as, low gasoline prices. Now that we are past summer drive season, I don’t see a large hit to consumer spending soon, but if gasoline prices are higher come spring, then next year’s summer drive season could be subdued and along with it, consumer spending. Skip-straight recession anybody?

If I Had To Make A Stock Market Prediction

This chart is provided by Raymond James’ Jeffrey Saut.

S&P 500 New Asset Allocation WeightsInterestingly, Saut called a new secular bull market way back in 2010 after openly pondering the question 2009. I never really believed him, but the evidence is starting to go his way. 

Crestmont Research believes we still have a final shoe to drop in the bear market that started in 2000 that went through the financial crisis. They believe this is a cyclical bull market within a secular bear market. I’m not so sure anymore. 

Here’s what I know, the next crash could be bad or really bad.

S&P Risk and SupportUnlike some analysts, I doubt we ever see a bear market that takes us anywhere where near the lows of 2009. Why? Simply put, there’s a lot more money now in the world to buy assets. And, we know now that central banks will print money, or at least borrow again via QE, if really needed to avoid a depression. 

Again, I don’t think a crash is imminent, but a correction of 5-10% might be. See the Yusko graphic above. I predicted a 9% to 19% correction for earlier this year. It happened.

Does that make me prescient? Nope. But I have a process that makes sense. I call it Core 4. Simply put, I consider in order: 

  1. Secular and macro trends.
  2. Government and Central Bank actions.
  3. Sector and company fundamentals.
  4. Asset price trends with a focus on reversals. 

What does that do for me? It helps me narrow down the ranges and do some scenario role play. While I believe my forecast for a strong Santa Claus rally is probably right, we can adjust if circumstances change. Price trends will largely dictate any short-term hedging or leverage. 

Right now, I am holding about 25% cash in portfolios because as I’ve discussed risk is high. Valuations and buybacks are conspiring against us at some point. But, for now, the trend is our friend. We’ll see how long that lasts. 

My holding cash has led to very good returns since I decided to take on new clients a while back. Many believe that being fully invested is important to returns. I differ, I believe building cash with dividends, option sells and occasional stock or ETF trims (and outright sells) is important in obtaining “optionality.”

Optionality is essentially the ability to strike when the iron is hot. For investors, you can’t “buy low” if you have no cash. There is something that is good and cheap in the markets on a regular basis, so building up cash, whether through savings or investment management should be part of any investors process.

Here is my independently verified composite returns the past 7 quarters: 

So, we have crushed the S&P 500 (SPY) and matched the Powershares QQQ (QQQ) despite holding a huge cash position on average. Simple ebb and flow trading with about half of portfolio values and selling options occasionally has been the secret sauce. This composite includes both conservative and aggressive accounts by the way, so there is a wide range on returns above and below the shown average. 

So, here’s my prediction. I am a likely put seller and stock buyer in October with the cash we hold. However, if the market doesn’t come back to us a bit, then we won’t be and we’ll ride along with the energy, telecom and tech heavy portfolio we currently have until a better opportunity presents to get more fully invested. 

Disclosure: I/we have no positions in any stocks mentioned, and no plans to initiate any positions within the next 72 hours.

I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it. I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article.

Related Articles


Get alerts when we publish a new idea!

Get Our Investment Ideas
Fully Confidential